{"meta":{"version":"2.1","_links":{"self":{"href":"https://api.vam.ac.uk/v2/object/O923771"},"collection_page":{"href":"https://collections.vam.ac.uk/item/O923771/"}},"images":{"_primary_thumbnail":"https://framemark.vam.ac.uk/collections/2017KN2005/full/!100,100/0/default.jpg","_iiif_image":"https://framemark.vam.ac.uk/collections/2017KN2005/","_alt_iiif_image":[],"imageResolution":"high","_images_meta":[{"assetRef":"2017KN2005","copyright":"©Victoria and Albert Museum, London","sensitiveImage":false}]},"see_also":{"_iiif_pres":"https://iiif.vam.ac.uk/collections/O923771/manifest.json","_alt_iiif_pres":[]}},"record":{"systemNumber":"O923771","accessionNumber":"D.5-1891","objectType":"Drawing","titles":[{"title":"Two designs for the inset paintings in the lower wall of the Great Hall at Moor Park, Hertfordshire","type":""}],"summaryDescription":"These drawings are designs for the inset paintings in the lower wall of the Great Hall at Moor Park, Hertfordshire, commissioned by its new owner Benjamin Haskins Styles. The drawing at the top of the sheet depicts Alexander the Great’s arrival in Jerusalem as told by Josephus in Jewish Antiquities. The composition is very similar to that of D.19-1891, which shows the design within its architectural setting. This was the design that was executed by Thornhill but was later removed and replaced with the work of another painter, following a disagreement with Styles over payment.\r\n\r\nThe drawing at the bottom of the sheet is a design for the painting and depicts the exiled Roman general Coriolanus listening to the pleas of his mother, wife and matrons of Rome to cease his attack on Rome, as described in Plutarch’s Lives. Thornhill sketched the composition in pen and ink, enhancing the darker passages with a blue/grey wash.","physicalDescription":"Drawing in pencil, pen and ink with blue wash. Alternative designs for the inset paintings in the lower wall of the Great Hall at Moor Park, Hertfordshire. ","artistMakerPerson":[{"name":{"text":"James Thornhill","id":"A8916"},"association":{"text":"","id":""},"note":""}],"artistMakerOrganisations":[],"artistMakerPeople":[],"materials":[{"text":"pen and ink","id":"x30618"},{"text":"wash","id":"AAT11051"},{"text":"pencil","id":"x30347"}],"techniques":[{"text":"drawing","id":"x32498"}],"materialsAndTechniques":"","categories":[{"text":"Drawings","id":"THES48966"}],"styles":[],"collectionCode":{"text":"PDP","id":"THES48595"},"images":["2017KN2005"],"imageResolution":"high","galleryLocations":[{"current":{"text":"LVLH","id":"THES49654"},"free":"","case":"PD","shelf":"86","box":"D"}],"partTypes":[[{"text":"drawing","id":""}]],"contentWarnings":[{"apprise":"","note":""}],"placesOfOrigin":[{"place":{"text":"Britain","id":"x32019"},"association":{"text":"","id":""},"note":""}],"productionDates":[{"date":{"text":"c.1725","earliest":"1720-01-01","latest":"1729-12-31"},"association":{"text":"","id":""},"note":""}],"associatedObjects":[{"object":{"text":"D.4-1891","id":"O923772"},"association":""},{"object":{"text":"D.18-1891","id":"O923758"},"association":""},{"object":{"text":"D.19-1891","id":"O923757"},"association":""}],"creditLine":"","dimensions":[{"dimension":"Height","value":"290","unit":"mm","qualifier":"","date":{"text":"","earliest":null,"latest":null},"part":"","note":""},{"dimension":"Width","value":"242 ","unit":"mm","qualifier":"","date":{"text":"","earliest":null,"latest":null},"part":"","note":""}],"dimensionsNote":"","marksAndInscriptions":[{"content":"Above the drawing at the top of the sheet: ‘Alex. & Jaddus. Jos: p.286’ with ‘10’ written below.\r\n\r\nAbove the drawing at the bottom of the sheet: ‘Marc: Coriolanus Xc, Plut. Vol. 2. P.157’ with ‘12’ written below","inscriber":{"name":{"text":"","id":""},"association":{"text":"","id":""}},"date":{"text":"","earliest":null,"latest":null},"description":"","interpretation":"","language":"","medium":"","method":"","position":"","script":"","translation":"","transliteration":"","type":"","note":"‘Jos’ refers to Josephus’s Jewish Antiquities, a 20-volume history of the Jewish people written by the Jewish historian Josephus around 93-94 AD. In describes the story of Alexander the Great’s arrival in Jerusalem, which Thornhill depicts in this drawing.\r\n\r\n‘Plut’ refers to Plutarch’s Lives of the Noble Greeks and Romans, a series of 48 biographies of famous Greek and Roman men probably written at the beginning of the second century AD.\r\n\r\nThe numbers ’10’ and ‘12’ probably refer to the size of the paintings being 10 and 12 feet respectively. This is evidenced by using the scale provided along the bottom of D.19-1891. The inset painting in this drawing, which relates to D.5-1891, measures 10 feet."}],"objectHistory":"Provenance: purchased from W.J. Smith in 1891\r\n\r\nThis drawings came to the museum as part of an album containing drawings and engravings chiefly by Thornhill. The album was dismantled and the works remounted.\r\n\r\nAs well as being a painter, Thornhill worked as an architect and was responsible for rebuilding Moor Park between 1720 and 1728 in addition to carrying out its interior decoration. This is the only surviving building that can be securely attributed to Thornhill and was his last major commission. In August 1728, Vertue noted that Thornhill painted eight inset paintings representing the heroic virtues, taken ‘from several stories of the Antients, Greeks, & Latins & Britons’ (Vertue notebooks III, Walpole Society, vol. 22 (1933-4), p.35).\r\n\r\nThis design was unrealised but another scheme (D.19-1891) was devised and executed by Thornhill. However, in 1728 Thornhill took out a lawsuit against Styles over payment for his work at Moor Park. Shortly afterwards Styles removed Thornhill’s paintings and commissioned Giacomo Amigoni (1682-1752) to make replacements ‘no doubt intended as a mortification to [Thornhill]’ (Vertue notebooks III, Walpole Society, vol. 22 (1933-4), p.63). The Venetian painter worked in collaboration with two other Italian artists for this project, Francesco Sleter (1685-1775) and Gaetano Brunetti (d.1758). \r\n\r\nThe sale catalogue for Thornhill’s posthumous sale, Sir James Thornhill’s Collection, 24, 25 February 1734 (lot 17) lists ‘All the Designs of the Buildings and Pictures at Moor Park’. Catalogue republished in Tancred Borenius, ‘Sir James Thornhill’s collection’, Burlington Magazine, no. 82 (1943), pp.133-37.","historicalContext":"","briefDescription":"Drawing, Two designs for the inset painting in the lower wall of the Great Hall at Moor Park, Hertfordshire by Sir James Thornhill, pencil, pen and ink with wash, ca.1725","bibliographicReferences":[{"reference":{"text":"","id":""},"details":"","free":"J. Simon, English Baroque Sketches: The Painted Interior in the Age of Thornhill, Marble Hill, 1974, no. 59\r\n\r\nT.P. Hudson, ‘Moor Park, Leoni and Sir James Thornhill’, The Burlington Magazine, vol. 133, no. 824 (Nov. 1971), pp. 657-61"},{"reference":{"text":"","id":""},"details":"","free":"Francois Marandet, 'James Thornhill versus Benjamin Styles: a painting from Moor Park rediscovered,' The Burlington Magazine (June 2026), pp. 576-581."}],"production":"","productionType":{"text":"","id":""},"contentDescription":"","contentPlaces":[],"associatedPlaces":[],"contentPerson":[],"associatedPerson":[],"contentOrganisations":[],"associatedOrganisations":[],"contentPeople":[],"associatedPeople":[],"contentEvents":[],"associatedEvents":[],"contentOthers":[],"contentConcepts":[],"contentLiteraryRefs":[],"galleryLabels":[],"partNumbers":["D.5-1891"],"accessionNumberNum":"5","accessionNumberPrefix":"D","accessionYear":1891,"otherNumbers":[],"copyNumber":"","aspects":["WHOLE"],"assets":[],"recordModificationDate":"2026-06-08","recordCreationDate":"2009-06-30","availableToBook":false}}